Facebook Beacon Is Dead. Long Live Amazon Grapevine.
March 13, 2008 1 Comment
Amazon has just come out with two new Facebook apps, as reported by Erick Schonfeld on TechCrunch. One is Amazon Giver, which lets friends share wish lists. The other is Amazon Grapevine, which lets you broadcast your activities on Amazon back to the Facebook newsfeed.
Pardon me…but isn’t that the basis of Facebook Beacon? Well, sort of. There are a few differences.
Amazon made this completely opt-in, which differs from the opt-out philosophy of Beacon. Also, product purchases are not included in Grapevine, but they were an important part of Beacon.
Personally, Beacon doesn’t bother me that much. I did not experience the early versions of Beacon with the too-fast notice that popped up on e-tailers’ sites. No accidentally revealing an engagement ring purchase. But there are times a purchase says something about you.
In fact, I think the idea of sharing your purchases with your friends has a lot of interesting potential. I can think of three different reasons people would share purchase information with friends and check out what their friends have purchased:
- Product discovery
- Friends’ reviews
I’ve mapped those reasons to several different retail sectors.
- Apparel = self-expression
- Computer Hardware/Software = friends’ reviews
- Consumer Electronics = friends’ reviews, self-expression
- Home & Garden = self-expression, friends’ reviews
- Sporting Goods = self-expression, friends’ reviews
- Baby Products = product discovery, friends’ reviews
For instance, I think broadcasting your Apparel purchases is more a form of self-expression. People’s fashion tastes are an extension of themselves. Participation in some sort of Beacon-like program for Consumer Electronics, on the other hand, would be a chance to provide reviews to friends and read the reviews of your friends. And Baby Products would have a lot of discovery and reviews. See what your friends have purchased for their infants. Anyone who is a first-time parent knows the challenges of figuring out what to buy.
But, Beacon is still controversial, and Amazon doesn’t go as far as broadcasting purchases. So for now, we broadcast our ratings and reviews. This is pretty good. I can learn a lot from that.
The only problem is, the opportunities to share this way are still quite limited. Not too many e-tailers are doing this yet. However, Amazon has a rich history of driving innovation in e-tail. It was the early leader in e-tail. It was among the first to set up an affiliate program (Amazon Associates). It pioneered product recommendations.
So now it’s experimenting with the sharing of product-related information on social networks. Probably won’t be long before other e-tailers get on board.